Last Spring we met Dave Magpiong, a local teacher whose flavor was chosen for the My Oreo Creation Contest. We tasted all three cookies (Cherry Cola, Kettle Corn and Piña Colada) and Dave's vacation inspired flavor was 100% the best choice.
We're not just saying that to be nice. We know snacks. And that's how we know that his Piña Colada cookie should have won the contest, not the gross Cherry Cola flavor that was selected. Go back to our original review, we said their so-called winning cookie had weird Pop Rock-like crystals in the icing and tastes like Fruit Stripe Gum, which does not work in cookie form.
Sorry, Dave, you were robbed.